Baking recipes

Winter Squash chutney

December 9, 2008


Maybe this is a British thing, but there often isn’t anything better than some lovely soft cheese, a decent slice of bread, and some great chutney. Pair it with a glass of wine and you have a lunch fit for champions.

My love affair with chutney really started back in England, in my early twenties. A friend and I every weekend would go off for a walk through the countryside, chew the fat a bit (talk a bunch of complete crap), get thoroughly lost, but somehow always manage to end up at a pub.. Actually if you have been to England you will know it isn’t too hard to always end up a pub.

Lunch would be a pint of local ale, and a “Ploughmans”. A ploughmans lunch is really just a big piece of bread (normally a baguette), a honking big piece of cheese – most likely a local cheddar, and some chutney or pickle. Sometimes there would be lettuce, other times a wee bit of tomato. It didn’t matter, it was all about the cheese and chutney.

This was normally a mellow lunch out in the pub garden – looking over the countryside we just got completely lost through. The next few hours were then spent working our way home, slightly tipsy with bellies full.

But you know the funny thing. Since moving to Seattle 7 years ago I haven’t had chutney. I was never much of a fan of the jarred variety (normally Branston’s in England), it lacked a lot of character. I also thought it was just too much of a pain to make, but in all honesty I had never read a recipe for it.

The traditional British chutney is a pretty rich affair. Very flavorful with a mix of spices (but not “spicy”), and a decent balance of sugar and vinegar. Traditionally a dark brown sugar is used, which furthers the flavor with deep molasses. The spices would often include ginger and clove, making for a pretty flavorful mix – especially once it has been fermenting for a while!


So chutney is really just a mix of vegetables, fruit, sugar, vinegar and spices that have all cooked together for a while. The trick is balancing the sweet with the acidity (vinegar). The trick is also letting it ferment in the fridge long enough to get some decent flavor out of it. I think I mentioned in my last post that I am rather impatient.. well, making chutney and curing meat are two things I never thought I would do because of this.


The first chutney I made a few months ago was using a recipe from the excellent “River Cottage Cookbook” by Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall. This was a very traditional English chutney, spice forward and a little sweet. It was good. Very good. In fact, it is so good I have even managed to leave a container of it in the back of the fridge for a couple of months without touching it. I think I will open it in January for a special occasion.

The chutney that I present to you here is my modification of Hugh’s original recipe. The veg and fruits are changed. I am now using a mix of white and brown sugar (to cut back some of the molasses flavor), and a different range of spices. I have however kept the basic ratios of things the same – there is no need to mess around with them, the original is a pretty well balanced chutney.

The main spice flavors here are sage and coriander seed – two flavors I just love with winter squash. You can use practically any squash you want. A combination is nice – even if it is just to prevent boredom peeling and chopping the same kind of squash all the time.

So this recipe is great for all you CSA freaks out there. I know you lot.. you at this time have 10000lb’s of winter squash sitting in your pantry, and not much else. Nothing wrong with that, but you can only roast so much of it.

Thankfully, this recipe will make even the largest tower of squash look a lot smaller by the time you are done peeling and dicing, and for this recipe you will be doing A LOT of peeling and dicing.

Talk about a recipe to hone those knife skills, and give you blisters.

It is worth it though. Cheese just seems kinda naked now without chutney.

This is really a recipe for a lazy afternoon. It takes a while. Just the prep work takes a couple of hours. The cooking is around 3 hours. I find the whole chopping part far more agreeable, and in fact enjoyable with a glass of wine, but that goes for a lot of things in life!

Oh – every veg and fruit gets peeled and diced. I wouldn’t worry a crazy amount about getting the perfect dice here.. It is cooking for 3 hours – slight variations in dice size isn’t really going to effect the cooking of each dice piece!


Winter Squash Chutney

4lb of winter squash (any variety, or a combination) – diced

1lb of cooking apples – cored, peeled and diced

1lb of onions – peeled and diced

1lb of golden raisins or sultanas

3/4lb white sugar

1/4lb light brown sugar

2 1/2 cups of white wine vinegar

a pinch of salt

a handful of sage leaves

30-40 corriander seeds (roughly)

1 teaspoon of black peppercorns


Put the corriander seeds, sage and black peppercorns in a piece of cheesecloth, and tie up the end – this is our spice bag.

Combine all the other ingredients in a large saucepan, and put the spice bag in. Bring this slowly to the boil, then cook uncovered for 2 to 3 hours. Stir occasionally.

The chutney is done when it is reduced, and if you run a spoon through it the mixture should stay parted so you can see the bottom of the pan.

Allow the chutney to cool slightly, then put into sterilized jars.

Store the jars in the fridge (some people see no problem leaving them on a pantry shelf however – apparently the ferment better that way… I am sure they do) for at least two weeks before munching.. 2 months however will make the chutney even better.

You Might Also Like

  • Dawn December 9, 2008 at 7:22 am

    Ok, yes, my pile of squash is still sitting there. And this recipe is just perfect – I think it will be a good project for my holiday time off. But I might as well put the band-aids on my fingers before I even start.

    BTW, I made that squash tart on Brittany’s blog, which you’d recommended, and it was awesome. Best Thanksgiving pie ever.

  • sue bette December 9, 2008 at 11:46 am

    I am totally psyched about this recipe – I love plating up these kind of bites for weekend lunch or an afternoon snack. The weather dipped to a chilly 1F yesterday, so any projects that encourage me to stay inside are welcome!

  • mattwright December 9, 2008 at 6:32 pm

    Dawn – I am so glad the squash tart worked out! Brittany’s blog is great, one of my favorites. I am with you with the band-aids. I don’t know what it is right now, but my hands are a mess! cuts, burns.. I have to start being more careful.

    Sue Bette – This is my complete go-to dinner too.. some bread, cheese, wine and chutney. Sure, not the most balanced meal in history, but sometimes that is all you want! It is goes pretty well with cold meats too – especially pork.. but my fav. is with cheese.

  • Heather December 9, 2008 at 8:25 pm

    Gorgeous! This is the spitting image of a stuffed squash dish I make, but in chutney form. 🙂 I like mine with a veined cheese like Roquefort, and some walnut meats.

    I’m still working on my chutneys and pickles for the season, and this is great inspirado to keep going.

  • Y December 10, 2008 at 8:22 am

    This sounds so good! I’ve never had a squash chutney before. Must confess though, I have occasional cravings for Branston pickle. There’s nothing subtle about it, but sometimes that’s just what I fancy with a nice piece of strong cheddar.

  • Food Woolf December 10, 2008 at 7:40 pm

    Uh, yum! I had no idea I had a craving for squash chutney until just now! Thanks for the amazing recipe. I guess I’m going to have to go make it….now!

  • We Are Never Full December 11, 2008 at 12:36 pm

    it’s kind of a british thing but i’ve been hooked by my husband. not quite the same thing, but i never would’ve thought of bringing a cheese and branston pickle sandwich for lunch, but, yup… do that now too!

  • redmenace December 12, 2008 at 6:04 am

    This looks fantastic and I think your table is fabulous too!

  • helen December 12, 2008 at 6:47 pm

    I’ll be making this during the holiday break. A friend recently inherited her mother’s canning supplies, and I’ve managed to wrangle her into this as well. Looks yummy!

  • Rhiannon December 13, 2008 at 2:55 am

    Matt – sorry to ask this on your blog but I can’t seem to find your email anywhere!

    Can I bring a dessert on Sunday? Maybe a simple aple tart or something?


  • MPG December 13, 2008 at 5:06 am

    I have to admit, I’ve never had a squash chutney…sounds yummy especially with the sage & coriander combo. I do have some squash sitting around…hmmm…

  • Leah December 13, 2008 at 5:37 pm

    What a great idea, Matt. And it’s perfect for all the leftover squash I have from baking squash chips! It also would make an excellent foodie gift. How’s the bresaola coming?

  • White On Rice Couple December 14, 2008 at 8:08 pm

    I think this would be a great x-mas gift beyond the traditional cookies! Sharing something traditionally English that goes great with cheese sounds perfectly fitting for the season!
    We love your stories of back home in England Matt! Keep em up. You make us feel like we’re there….countryside….pub and all!

  • brittany December 15, 2008 at 10:49 pm

    Soft cheese, crusty bread, and chutney. Pretty much the perfect plate of nibbles! I probably am too impatient to make chutney (I wanna eat NOW), luckily friends and loved ones know this and always send me little jars for christmas…..hint..
    This recipe looks worth the wait to let it ferment. I should probably give it a go.

  • Kirsten December 16, 2008 at 1:08 am

    wow, this looks just dreamy. I grew up on Waitrose tomato chutney, ploughman’s pickle, and english cheddar smuggled back from visiting my cousins. I can’t believe you’ve gone seven years without! I had made some sweet pepper and chili chutney that is almost gone, so I will be testing this one out immediately. seems like a perfect melange of flavors; nice adaptation.

  • Helen December 18, 2008 at 12:55 pm

    Well a ploughmans is actually one of my all time favourite meals! Seriously! I am British after all 🙂 I think using squash in a chutney is a brilliant idea too – why didn’t I think of that? I shall just have to be content with tryng your absolutely gorgeous recipe – and the colour !Will brighten up any Ploughman’s – hmm, bread and cheese!

  • helen January 5, 2009 at 9:47 pm

    I got together with a few girlfriends to make the chutney this past weekend. It was so much fun, and the recipe is just fabulous! I wouldn’t change it one bit – it is peferectly sweet and tart. We ended up with 10, 250 mL jars. The hardest part was to not eat it all right away (we did eat some; oops).

  • » Blog Archive » Seattle Food Bloggers Meat Party!!! January 21, 2009 at 5:48 pm

    […] the chutney. I made a Winter Squash chutney a while back now, that goes wonderfully with soft cheeses. Before that I made a more traditional […]

  • Teri Lyn Fisher February 8, 2009 at 3:50 am

    This looks so pretty! What amazing colors. Nice shot. I must try this!

  • Cynthia Robinson December 24, 2010 at 6:17 pm

    That was the most fun I’ve ever had reading a recipe! Thank you so much for the story behind it, and for what will prove to be the best chutney I’ve ever had, I’m sure!